A long time customer-friend send me a link to this interesting article about France’s culture minister “attack” on Amazon:
France’s culture minister has attacked Amazon, the online retailer, for deliberately undercutting traditional rivals to create a “quasi-monopoly”..
..Calling Amazon a “destroyer of bookshops”, she added that she was considering a ban on free postage offers and a current regime of allowable 5 per cent discounts on books.
The only thing I don’t understand is why they use so many quotation marks. What Amazon does is even worse than “dumping” and the monopoly that they are after is even worse than “quasi-monopoly”. And, yes – they are a “destroyer of bookshops”.
I absolutely agree that Amazon should abide by a certain set of rules. First of all – they should pay taxes. Secondly, they should improve working conditions in their sweatshops. And, yes, maybe they should even stop using books as a loss leader for their other merchandize.
While it’s true that France (like any other non-English speaking national state) can protect their own book-selling eco-systems (“exception culturelle”) – I still think that there’s nothing we can do to prevent Amazon from ultimately destroying the English language book-selling eco-system.
The Book Depository (established in 2005 by an Amazon drop-out and acquired by Amazon in July 2011) will ship any English language book at a dumping price to any place on Earth.
Good news is that I approach this shit from a new angle. I understand Amazon as an agent of change. No doubt – an evil, right wing agent of change. But, the truth is: it forces us, mainly small booksellers and small publishers, to think in new creative ways. It polarizes. And that is good.
Books are subversive! So subversive like they haven’t been in a long while. Books in OWS Library. Books in Gezi Park. Books are tools of civil disobedience. Kindle is not. Thanks, Amazon.
About a month ago I shared some of my opinions with Agata Tomažič for her article on the current state of book-selling (article is in Slovene). Here are some of my thoughts:
What happens to books? Nothing. Books are doing better than ever. They are finally getting rid of all the unnecessary shit that became “books” during the times when printed books were the industrial standard for a long form narrative.
What happens to the book-business? It’s over. Amazon and the Pirate Bay dismantled it. Very few booksellers will survive. Internet towards copyright industry is like if someone pulled out the plug from the bathtub.
The good news is that the water in the bath was already lukewarm before Amazon and the Pirate Bay. During the eighties the fast growing English language book-business entered some kind of a Rococo phase. Publishing became a corporate industry.
The Pirate Bay is, in my opinion, that progressive, left wing agent of change that might force us to redefine our copyright laws. These laws, in their present state, protect corporations and victimize people.
Digital text is different from physical text. Files shared via the Pirate Bay are not books at all. Enabling sharing in this case is enabling a new life for a long form narrative. It’s reincarnating. It is a first step towards something new and different.
It might sound crazy, but in my view the Pirate Bay and the world of physical books are complementary. The Pirate Bay emphasizes community. It puts people before profits. This is why it should be our preferred agent of change.
Article in Financial Times
Članek v Pogledih
The Pirate Bay – Away from Keyboard
Peter Sunde blog
Die Andersdenkenden